Traffic:   23 Incidents
Weather: 51°F Go
  08:06am PST, 12/01/08
Local News
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Posted: Thursday, 28 August 2008 5:43PM

The Instant Replay Debate

SAN FRANCISCO (KCBS/AP)  -- Jim Evans is a former Major League umpire with 28 years of experience under his belt. He believes that instant replay has its place in baseball. In fact, he says today's new "fan friendly" ball parks have contributed to the necessity of instant replay.

“A lot of fans can get real close that baseball’s technically still in play, and some spectator interference calls where fans reach over and touch the ball, it happens in like a millisecond, and it’s almost impossible for an umpire, who is a couple hundred feet away, to make the absolute certain call every time.”

While Evans is supportive of instant replay, he also cautions that it can be misused and warns of what he doesn’t want the new technology to become:

“…just for it to become a crutch, and for umpires to develop the mental attitude that ‘ok, no big deal, we’ve got an instant replay if we mess something up,’ … and that’s the wrong mindset for an umpire.”

The current plan is to use instant replay only to determine if a ball has cleared a fence, if it was foul or fair, or if a fan interfered with a play. Evans cautions that umpires will have to be very judicious in how they use this new tool for the game.

On Wednesday, Major League Baseball announced that umpires will be allowed to check video on home run calls starting Thursday after the MLB, guardian of America's most traditional sport, reversed its decades-long opposition to instant replay.

The replay central itself is an 18-by-24 foot room on the fifth floor of a former baking factory in Manhattan's Meatpacking District, containing hundreds of television and computer monitors. Video from the 30 major league ballparks are already being collected and will be made available to umpires starting Thursday to help them with home-run calls. Technicians can zoom in on replays and run them at any speed.

The NFL first used replay to aid officials in 1986, the NHL in 1991 and the NBA in 2002.

Listen KCBS' Susan Leigh Taylor reports  Susan Leigh Taylor

 

(cfu)


(Copyright 2008, KCBS. All Rights Reserved. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)
 
 
In the Kitchen with Narsai David
John Madden
Jan Wahl
Larry Magid
Charles Osgood
Dave Ross
Tom Stienstra Outdoors Report
Phil Matier
About the Bay




Print Page Email This Page
 
 

KCBS

Top News
Peaceful End to Redwood City Standoff
Some Tahoe Ski Resorts Don't Make the Grade
Coast Guard Warns of High Surf
Bicyclists Honor AIDS Victims
Small Crowds for Sunday Holiday Travelers
Two Dead in Capsized Boat
Holiday DUI Arrests Down
Sharing the Road with Bicyclists
Sonar Testing to Resume Off California Coast
Higher Education Helps Welfare Families Earn Higher Wages
'No Confidence' Vote for SJ Fire Chief
San Francisco Vigil for Mumbai Victims
Bee Keepers Hope for Wet Winter
Customers Line Up to Purchase Christmas Trees
Not For Tourists-- a Guide for Locals
Writers Race to Meet One Month Novel Challenge Deadline
Paying Off Credit Debt Should be No. 1 Priority
Healdsburg Winery Offers Eco-Friendly Tube
Friends and Family Mourn Loss of Cyclist
Military Families Frustrated by Lack of War Coverage
Recycling Up in Bad Economy
Online Coupons Catch On in Bad Economic Times
Budget Cuts Impact CSU Enrollment
BART Opponents Demand Recount
SF City Leader Confronts Police on MUNI Safety
Remembering George Moscone and Harvey Milk
Icahn Raises His Stake in Yahoo!
Shoppers Hit the Malls
Cristo Rey School to Open in Bay Area
Lake Tahoe Ski Resort Openings Delayed
Reward Offered in Fatal Hit and Run Case
O'Connell Worries about Budget Impasse
Public Hearing Planned for UC Merced